Sleep tech only seems to be getting more pervasive, permanent, and pricey. One day, you start checking your sleep rings on your Apple Watch, the next, you find yourself shopping for smart mattresses that require you to rethink your entire bed, fans that blow cool air under your duvet, and subscription apps that promise sleep coaching with hyper-granular data. Smart sleep pads are a good middle ground. They don’t require you to replace your bed and frame, strap anything to your body, or radically change your routine. They just sit on or underneath your mattress or pillow, and quietly do their thing—from tracking to temperature regulation—while you sleep.

Some smart sleep pads adjust temperature, while others monitor movement or ever-so-slightly influence your sleep patterns. Either way, they’re easy to live with, which feels closer to how we think tech should behave at night. I tested several sleep pads on the same bed, during a Midwestern winter, to see which ones truly felt like they made a difference, and which felt more like experiments than solutions. All testing was done on a king-size Purple Restore Cool Touch mattress with a standard fitted cotton sheet and my beloved Mellow comforter. Using the same bed, bedding, and sleep routine throughout helped isolate what each pad actually changed (or didn’t) about my sleep. As a way to measure and mildly improve sleep without rethinking your entire routine, they were surprisingly effective.

Be sure to check out our other sleep-related guides, including the Best Mattresses, Best Mattress Toppers, Best Sheets, and Best Sleep Trackers.

Best for Temperature Regulation

Every night, what excites me most about crawling into bed (other than catching up on a few episodes of Below Deck), is knowing that I’m about to settle into a warm one. The Smart Topper from Perfectly Snug is a temperature-regulating mesh pad that fits on top of your mattress underneath your fitted sheet, actively warming and cooling you while you sleep. I was hesitant at first: I’m extremely loyal to my Purple mattress and didn’t want to give up its pillowy surface. Perfectly Snug’s airy pad was surprisingly supportive and comfortable, landing somewhere around a medium-firm feel.

Setup is straightforward: Plug it in, lay it on the bed, put fresh sheets over it, and connect to Wi-Fi via Perfectly Snug’s app. From there, you enter your weekly bedtime and wake-up schedule and adjust settings such as foot-heater strength and the aggressiveness of cool bursts. Once programmed, the pad starts warming up an hour before your set bedtime. If you have the Dual Zone option, each side of the bed can be adjusted independently, which spared my husband from my preference for warmth. The app’s interface does feel a little beta, like it belongs on an old iPod Touch next to Temple Run, but it works.

From there, your night’s temperature is (mostly) in the Smart Topper’s hands. Cooling happens through the nearly silent fans that kick on when sensors detect rising body heat, and it’ll warm you when it senses you’re getting cold. If you want to override the automation, physical buttons on the side of the topper let you adjust cooling or heating without having to squint at your phone in the middle of the night. For anyone who runs hot at night, the Smart Topper’s an effective, fuss-free way to stay comfortable.

Value: 9/10: The Perfectly Snug smart topper is pricey up front, but it delivers something that would otherwise require a new mattress or higher power bills. For hot sleepers especially, the cooling feature can replace multiple workarounds (fans, AC toggles, frequent sheet changes).

Comfort: 8/10: The pad is noticeable, but not bothersome. It does slightly change the feel of your mattress, but the mesh construction is breathable and supportive. And once you’re used to it, the real comfort payoff is exactly what the pad’s for: consistent temperature regulation.

How the tech performs: 7/10: The automated heating and cooling works well, and the fans are quiet. The app looks dated and is a bit hard to navigate, but once you figure it out, it does what it needs to do. Physical buttons on the side to adjust temperature are a big plus.

Best for Discreet Sleep Tracking

The best thing about the Withings Sleep Pad is how easy it is to forget it’s there. This smart mattress pad from the health tech company that makes our favorite smart scale slips right under your mattress and, aside from a single plug, is completely unobtrusive. There’s nothing to activate on a nightly basis, no buttons to mess with, and nothing about it changes how your bed feels. You can charge your smartwatch all night and not worry about the battery dying the next afternoon because you wanted to track your sleep. To me, that’s peak smart sleep tracking: Technology that does its job quietly and stays out of the way.

The pad uses two sensors to collect data. The pneumatic sensor tracks heart and respiratory rates as well as your movements through ballistography, which essentially means it detects tiny vibrations your body makes as your heart beats and you breathe, while the sound sensor identifies snoring and breathing disturbances. Together, they build a picture of your night and give you a sleep score. It can also flag potential sleep apnea events (though that data is clearly framed by Withings as informational, not diagnostic—see a doctor if you have concerns about sleep apnea). Each morning, the app also gives a quick assessment of your breathing quality, and a chart shows how it fluctuated throughout the night.

The tracking appears accurate based on my testing in a non-lab environment. My wake-up and bedtimes closely matched what my Garmin Lily 2 smartwatch recorded over two weeks of testing, and the nightly data told a similar story of my sleep patterns. I never changed my bedtime or sleep behavior based on the scores, but it was reassuring to see patterns emerge night after night.

Value: 8/10: For the price, the Withings pad has solid sleep tracking with zero lifestyle disruption, which is a huge perk. You’re paying for passive insight, but not necessarily being told what to do about it.

Comfort: 10/10: This sleeping pad doesn’t affect mattress feel, make noise, or demand any interaction to work, aside from initial setup. Once installed, it becomes functionally invisible.

How the tech performs: 8/10: Tracking lined up closely with my smartwatch data and how I felt overall. The breathing quality insights were genuinely interesting rather than just a filler feature. It’s not diagnostic and doesn’t claim to be, but as a basic sleep tracker, it’s reliable and easy to trust and is a great solution for people who don’t want to wear a tracker on their wrist or finger.

Best for Sleep Coaching

When I first looked into the Hapbee Sleep Pad, the marketing was vague enough that I assumed it was just another smart sleep sensor that would track and analyze sleep like many others. It wasn’t until I set up the pad and worked my way through the instructions that I realized just how technologically ambitious this little device is.

On the Hapbee app, you choose from a library of “Vibes,” which are presets of micro-magnetic fields meant to mimic the signals associated with mental states like relaxation and deep sleep. The pad itself—about the size and thickness of a heating pad—sits under your pillow and emits those frequencies once activated in the app. The idea is that your body picks up on these signals and responds in a way that makes it easier to fall asleep or stay asleep.

From what I could tell, it worked. I’m already a deep sleeper, so I didn’t notice any difference in overall sleep quality, but I fell asleep faster when using the Hapbee for its intended purpose. I alternated nights using a Vibe with nights I didn’t, so I could compare my sleep stats. On days I used a Vibe (ranging from Deep Sleep to Zen Companion), there was almost no wake time before I drifted off. Whether that’s placebo, physiology, or some combination of the two is hard to say, but the difference was consistent enough that I noticed it.

Scores

Value: 6/10: This depends heavily on your comfort level with experimental-feeling tech. It’s not cheap, and while it did help with falling asleep faster, it’s harder to quantify long-term value, especially if you’re already a decent sleeper.

Comfort: 7/10: You definitely notice the Hapbee under your pillow, especially if you’re like me and like to rest an arm under your pillow when you sleep. Hapbee also recommends placing it inside your pillowcase; it’s not uncomfortable, but you can feel its physical presence.

How the tech performs: 7/10: The micromagentic “Vibes” were easy to use and reliably helped me fall asleep faster, which counts for something. That said, the science still feels a little gimmicky, and the experience leans more towards an “interesting sleep experiment” rather than a permanent solution.

Power up with unlimited access to WIRED. Get best-in-class reporting and exclusive subscriber content that’s too important to ignore. Subscribe Today.